Sweet Pies

Mini Pies

We offer six different flavours of mini pies weekly to make up an itty bitty six pack or to be purchased in any amount. The mini pies usually include a fruit crumble, a couple of cream pies, a mini cream cheese and butter pecan. Any mini pie can be made into a 9" size. We are always coming up with new flavours but if you have a craving for a favorite flavour, let us know early in the week and we will try to fit it into the weekly line up!

Click to enlarge

Itty Bitty Six Pack $16

Butter Mini Pies

Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble

Niagara Peach Cream

9" PIES

Contact to order

If you don't see the flavour you are looking for, contact us. Give us at least 48 hours notice when ordering!

$17

Apple

Contains at least two types of local freshly peeled apples, lightly sugared and a touch of cinnamon. Choice of crumble or pastry.

$17

Cherry

Plump and juicy pre sweetened cherries from Cherry Lane makes this pie a winner. Decorated with a beautiful woven pastry lattice.

$17

Blueberry

Blueberries handpicked at the height of the season with abit of sugar tastes like summer. Choice of crumble or pastry.

$17

Strawberry Rhubarb or Rhubarb

Sweet local strawberries and rhubarb generously donated from family and customers. Choice of crumble or pastry.

$17

Mixed Berry

Strawberries, raspberries, and blackberries lightly sweetened, give this mixture the best sweet' n sour combo. Choice of crumble or pastry.

$17

Pumpkin

A creamy spiced pumpkin filling inside of our flaky pastry. Too good to be just for the holidays.

$17

$22

Coconut Cream

Our creamy filling is full of flaked coconut and pairs perfectly inside our buttery pastry with lots of real whipped cream and toasted coconut on top.

$22

Ultimate Sweet Potato Pie

An itty bitty speciality pie consisting of a creamy spiced sweet potato filling and topped with toasted marshmallows and crushed pecans. Then drizzled generously with our salted caramel sauce.

$22

$24

Key Lime

An itty bitty speciality pie. We use freshly squeezed key limes and our own graham cracker crust recipe....one bite and you feel like you are in Key West. Subject to availability.

$24

Strawberry Cream

Our creamy filling is full of chunks of real strawberries inside of our flaky pastry and heaped with real whipped cream.

$24

Peanut Butter Cream

What can we say.....one bite and you are hooked! A filling consisting of peanut butter, cream cheese and whipping cream inside of our graham cracker crust. Then topped with a hefty amount of real whipped cream and drizzled with our salted caramel and chocolate sauces.

$24

$18

Butter Pecan

This southern fave is heaped full of pecans in a not too runny filling.

$18

Click to enlarge

Lemon Poppyseed with Blueberries

Strawberry Rhubarb

Key Lime

Peanut Butter Cream

SAVOURY PIES

BEEF CHICKEN/TURKEY QUICHE, PORK & BEEF

$6.25 ea. / Mix & Match 4 @ $23

BEEF

Cabbage Roll

Ground beef, cabbage & rice all wrapped in our flaky pastry

Taco

Seasoned ground beef, black beans & cheddar cheese. Top with taco toppings after baking.

Steak & Guinness

Steak & potatoes in a heavy on the Guinness flavoured gravy.

Jamaican Meat Pie - Spicy

Ground beef seasoned with Caribbean spices & Scotch Bonnet to give it a little heat. The crust is different from the others, with curry pastry.

Steak & Kidney

Steak, kidney, potatoes & peas in a rich beef gravy & topped with puff pastry.

Chipotle Beef - Spicy

Ground beef, diced tomatoes, kidney beans, corn & chipotles & topped with cornbread.

Shepherds Pie

Ground beef & peas in a rich beef gravy & topped with buttery mashed potatoes.

$6.25 ea. / Mix & Match 4 @ $23

CHICKEN/TURKEY

Buffalo Chicken - Spicy

Chicken, carrots & celery in a creamy medium spicy sauce.

Curry Chicken

Chicken, potatoes & carrots in a bold Jamaican curry sauce.

Country Chicken

Chicken, carrots, peas & celery in a creamy herbed sauce.

Holiday Turkey Pie (Seasonal)

Turkey stew topped with cranberry sauce and then a mixture of stuffing and mashed potatoes. It tastes like the holidays! Seasonal

Butter Chicken

Chunks of chicken in a packed with flavorful Indian spiced tomato based sauce. Encased in our flaky pastry.

$6.25 ea. / Mix & Match 4 @ $23

QUICHE, PORK & BEEF

Tourtiere

Ground beef, ground pork & potatoes seasoned with herbs & spices unique to this French Canadian savoury pie.

Pork & Apple (Oct - March)

Seasoned pork, apples, celery & onions in a herbed gravy.

Jalapeno Bacon Mac'n cheese with Pulled Pork

A combo that entices all the senses! A bbq pulled pork topped with our creamy jalapeno/bacon mac'n cheese

$22

Quiche

A variety of flavours of offered based on seasonal vegetables.

$22

Click to enlarge

Buffalo Chicken

Cabbage Roll Pie

Chipotle Beef Pie

Jamaican Meat Pie

Jalapeno Bacon Mac'n Cheese with Pulled Pork

Shepherds Pie

Steak & Kidney

Taco

Tourtiere

VEGAN & VEGETARIAN

VEGAN VEGETARIAN

$6.25 ea. / Mix & Match 4 @ $23

VEGAN

Curry Chickpea

Chickpeas, potatoes & carrots in a tasty curry sauce.

Mushroom Lentil Pie

Mushrooms, lentils & carrots together in a herbed sauce.

Sweet Potato Chipotle

Seasoned veggie protein, diced tomatoes, kidney beans, corn & topped with mashed sweet potatoes

Buffalo Cauliflower

A mixture of cauliflower, carrots & celery in a spicy, almond milk sauce

Jamaican Pie

Veggie protein, scotch bonnet peppers & Caribbean spices make for a pie with some heat and great taste!

Pesto Veggie

Broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, kale, onion.....so many veggies! All together in a pesto flavoured almond milk sauce.

Fruit Pies

All of our fruit based pies are made without any animal products and encased in our flaky vegetable shortening pastry.

$6.25 / Mix & Match 4 @ $23

VEGETARIAN

BBQ & Mac'n Cheese - Vegan

Jack fruit flavoured with bbq sauce and liquid smoke all mixed together and topped with our vegan, flourless,creamy mac'n cheese.

Curry Chickpea - Vegan

Chickpeas, potatoes & carrots in a tasty curry sauce.

.Spinach & Feta - Vegetarian

Spinach, feta & baby tomatoes and topped with phyllo pastry.

Creamy Pesto Veggie - Vegan

Carrots, brocolli, cauliflower & kale in a creamy pesto sauce.

Herbed Mushroom - Vegetarian

White mushrooms & portabello mushrooms in a creamy herbed sauce. Topped with a savoury crumble.

Click to enlarge

Fruit Crumble

Pesto Veggie

Herbed Mushroom

Seasonal Veggie Quiche

Spinach Feta Quiche

Curry Chickpea

Mushroom Lentil

Sweet Potato Chipotle

Itty Bitty Frozen product

To be cooked in the comfort of your own home

$30

Itty Bitty Appetizers

The perfect tray to have on hand during the holidays. The tray goes into the oven for approx. 30 min. and voila.... Holiday availability

$30

Mac'n Cheese

Individual size Macaroni in a extra cheesy creamy sauce

$9 & $11 - 1 litre

Soups

Red Lentil, Loaded Potato, Turkey & Rice (Seasonal), Italian Wedding Soup, French Onion and West African Peanut Soup

$9 & $11 - 1 litre

Click to enlarge

Itty Bitty Appetizers

Jalapeno Bacon Cheddar Mac'n Cheese

Red Lentil Soup - Vegan Friendly

Extra Stuff

$8 - 250ml

Salted Caramel Sauce

This highly addictive sauce is great on a slice of apple pie, ice cream, popcorn, fruit or straight from the jar!

$8 - 250ml

$6 - 250ml

Southridge Jam Company

We are proud to offer three flavours of their amazing jam in our shop! Made with all local fruit (peach, strawberry & grape jelly) and proceeds are given back to our community.

$6 - 250ml

Salted Caramel Sauce

Southridge Jam Company (click on pic for website)